Smearcasting documents the public writings and appearances of Islamophobic activists and pundits who intentionally and regularly spread fear, bigotry and misinformation in the media. Offering a fresh look at Islamophobia and its perpetrators in today’s media, it also provides four snapshots, or case studies, describing how Islamophobes manipulate media in order to paint Muslims with a broad, hateful brush. PLEASE NOTE: The printed report and the text on these web pages was written in 2008. An Update page is now included.


Daniel Pipes' Witch Hunt at a Public School

In September 2007, the Khalil Gibran International Academy, named for the noted Lebanese Christian poet, became the country's first public school focused on Arabic language and culture. 

According to the New York Department of Education (Brooklyn Eagle, 7/30/07) the school was using "the same curriculum packages as other New York City public schools," and the chancellor of schools emphasized (Christian Science Monitor, 6/1/07) that its curriculum would be subject to departmental monitoring as with any other public school. 

In short, according to New York schools chancellor Joel Klein, it was not so different from the 60-plus other dual language schools already operating in New York. 

However, months before it opened its doors in Brooklyn, N.Y. the school came under fire from detractors who preemptively accused it of "imbuing pan-Arabism and anti-Zionism, proselytizing for Islam, and promoting Islamist sympathies" (New York Sun, 4/24/07). Charges were led by the New York Sun and its writer Daniel Pipes, a conservative Mideast historian who runs the Middle East Forum and Campus Watch. 

Pipes sits on the advisory board of the Stop the Madrassa Coalition (New York Times, 4/28/08), created, according to the coalition's blog (4/29/08), to end the "'soft jihad'...infiltrating our schools." Although "madrassa" is Arabic for "school," KGIA opponents used it to mean "a religious school" that would "impose a radical Islamic agenda in its classrooms" (CNN, 9/4/07). 

Pipes has long argued that "Arabic-language instruction is inevitably laden with pan-Arabist and Islamist baggage" (New York Sun, 4/24/07), and fellow Sun writer Alicia Colon wrote (5/1/07) that this "pandering to multiculturalism" must have "delighted Osama bin Laden." She then called on her readers to "break out the torches and surround City Hall to stop this monstrosity." 

Special abuse was reserved for Debbie Almontaser, the school's main founder who was also chosen to be its first principal. A prominent member of New York's Arab-American community, Almontaser earned praise for her work forging interfaith and interethnic alliances (New York Times, 4/28/08), but that history was omitted when right-wing media painted her as "a classic 'stealth Islamist'" (Weekly Standard, 4/11/08) with "an Islamist/leftist agenda" (Pipe Line News, 4/19/07).

Almontaser was further characterized by Pipes (New York Sun, 4/28/07) as a September 11 apologist in connection to her statement, "I don't recognize the people who committed the attacks as either Arabs or Muslims." Pipes failed to include Almontaser's following sentence (New York Times, 8/29/07): "Those people who did it have stolen my identity as an Arab and stolen my religion." 

Attacks on Almontaser intensified after the New York Post reported (8/6/07) that she had "downplayed the significance" of a T-shirt emblazoned with the phrase "Intifada NYC." The shirt was produced by the group Arab Women Active in Art and Media, a youth media group that shares office space with an organization on whose advisory board Almontaser sits. When asked by the Post about the T-shirts' use of the word "intifada," Almontaser says (New York Times, 4/28/08) she responded that she could not comment because neither she nor the school had anything to do with the shirts. The reporter followed up by asking Almontaser about the word itself, and she explained that it literally means a "shaking off." In an interview with the New York Times (4/28/08), Almontaser said that although she never spoke to the reporter about the T-shirts, she defended the girls in the organization because she believed that the reporter was set on "vilifying innocent teenagers." 

The Post began its article: "Activists with ties to the principal...are hawking T-shirts that glorify Palestinian terror," and the following day (8/7/07) concluded that "the hijab-wearing principal...has issued a fatwa against the kids of New York." "Why would this principal defend T-shirts celebrating a Palestinian uprising that has seen suicide bombers killing hundreds and hundreds of innocent Jews?" asked Rich Lowry, guest host on Hannity & Colmes (Fox News Channel, 8/10/07). 

In August 2007, as a result of the media onslaught, Almontaser resigned. She has subsequently said that she was forced to do so and is now suing the city of New York. The case is still pending, but in a ruling that denied her request to prevent the Department of Education from hiring a new principal, Judge Jon O. Newman concluded (New York Times, 4/28/08): "This was a situation where she was subject to sanction not for anything she said, not for anything she did, but because a newspaper reporter twisted what she said, and the result of it was negative press for the city and the Board of Ed."